The Halfway Point

 | Jul 09, 2019 12:19AM ET

A standing ovation to anyone who felt maximum investment pain on the last Christmas Eve. Had you stuck to your guns, your portfolio likely had an incredible rip higher during the first six months of 2019. Stocks were inches from a -20% bear market drawdown, energy commodities had pulled in by 40% and the credit markets were in a disorderly, illiquid retreat. The Fed took note (along with a threatening POTUS’ sand wedge) and flipped their policy direction from one of tightening to one of loosening. The markets reacted quickly and any investor who doesn’t look at their fourth quarter statements wouldn’t have even noticed. For trend-following investors however, we welcomed Santa with high fives, but then wanted to shoot both St. Patrick and the Easter Bunny. Hats off to the Buy and Hold crowd, you won this round.

So, what will the second half of 2019 have in store for investors? Well just because the first half was great, doesn’t always mean the second half follows. We still have to size up where we are in the world. Stock prices still tend to follow earnings. And because of the global trade and tariff wars, sales are coming up short, margins are being impacted and companies are more reluctant to want to invest. This has and will continue to pressure earnings as we will see in the weeks ahead. With the S&P 500 trading at about 3,000 and the 2020 earnings estimate for the index at about $180, that place the market’s forward price-to-earnings ratio at about 16.5x. Historically, this is not at a discount. Of course in the other corner, you have the Fed looking to lower interest rates while the Market has already front run them by cutting rates by nearly 100 basis points. Cut the interest rate by 1% in any of your DCF models and what do you get? A much higher value.

So welcome to the newest stock market tightrope that investors are going to walk. Falling economic data and earnings being offset by falling interest rates. This game has been playing in Europe for years. U.S. bond market investors are betting on a 25-basis point rate cut in July and then one in September, followed by another 25-50 over the following six months. If the global economy could stop slowing and the U.S. could keep out of a recession, then maybe U.S. stocks could see a melt up above 20x multiples take hold. But after 10 years of good times, could a soft landing be that smooth? Animal spirits have definitely run. We see it in the high percentage of loss-making companies going public. We see private equity takeovers at top valuations. We see aggressive non-bank lending on many asset classes, including art! Also, take note of the rapid growth in liquid investment vehicles holding non-liquid assets. It is probably time for a reminder of risk in the world, but the Fed and other Central Banks are also watching the markets closely. Rather than remind investors of irrational exuberance, they appear to be swapping the rum in the punch for moonshine.

Get The News You Want
Read market moving news with a personalized feed of stocks you care about.
Get The App

If the Fed does soft land this big plane then great for them and all of our risky assets. I am just not sure the downside risk is worth the reach for the upside reward right now. I would rather see growth in sales and earnings to push stock prices higher. I know that I am going to be ‘Fighting the Fed’ but I think that I have the inverted yield curve, trade wars and high valuations in my favor. It also seems that the odds of a market/business unfriendly 2020 POTUS is rising.

h2 First, a reminder that a great first half doesn’t always mean a great second half…/h2