Gold Mining Stocks' Holiday Rally Is Unsustainable

 | Jul 05, 2023 03:07AM ET

The U.S. markets were closed for Independence Day, but we just saw some fireworks in junior mining stocks. Will they rally independently from gold? Every now and then, miners really do manage to move independently from gold price moves, but this is rare, as ultimately, mining stocks’ revenues (thus profits) depend on the prices of the metals that they mine or are looking for.

In those cases, it could be that it’s the strength of the market is so great that miners’ strong performance simply represents it – and it’s a bullish factor then. However, in other cases, miners’ strength is very temporary and triggered by some sort of other event.

How can one tell which approach is correct? By looking at the context.

  • What happened beyond the price moves?
  • What kind of volume accompanied the price moves?
  • What happened on an intraday basis?

For example, yesterday, the VanEck Junior Gold Miners ETF (NYSE:GDXJ) – a proxy for junior mining stocks – moved sharply higher. However, it’s doubtful that this rally will turn into something sustainable. Here’s why: