Euro's False Negative Reaction

 | Oct 21, 2016 07:54AM ET

Forex News and Events

What happened at yesterday’s ECB meeting?

At yesterday’s ECB meeting, investors were expecting Mario Draghi to announce an extensions of QE beyond March 2017. No clear views were offered yesterday by Draghi but did hint at the extension of bond purchases. The dovish view still prevails and the tapering of the QE program does not seem even close. We maintain our view that QE will be extended and the amount purchases of €80 billion a month should remain unchanged for some time.

It appears very clear to us that the ECB December meeting will be the key meeting of this year. In order not to bring any further turmoil to the market, we believe that policymakers chose to opt this month for the status quo. It is also worth noting that Draghi is probably satisfied with the EUR/USD level which is now stalling below 1.10. This largely benefits Eurozone exporters and is bringing some relief to ECB officials.

Eurozone inflation rate remains very low at 0.4% and also well below the inflation target of 2%. It cannot be said that the ECB program has been efficient so far. Indeed, no one can say that the Eurozone economy has been stimulated knowing that growth remains somewhat sluggish. In terms of interest rates, we hold our dovish view even though we believe that there is little room for other rate cuts. From our vantage point, rates cannot go much deeper into negative territory or the risk of triggering a bank run will increase. There is no upside to the ECB to add some pressures on the banking sector, which is already at stake. Some major banks such as Deutsche Bank (DE:DBKGn) or Commerzbank (DE:CBKG) are making the headlines and this would only increase their difficulties.

Euro’s false negative reaction

Interestingly, despite the fact that Mario Draghi provided no clear indication that additional easing is certain, today the EUR/USD is -1.0% lower than prior to the ECB meeting. Our view is that the market is not listening to the ECB. They hear the words but show no comprehension of their meaning. Over the past ten years, markets have become so conditioned to get currency debasing easing every time that the inflation outlook deviates from the central bank’s target rate (in this case the ECB’s 2% target).

Despite Draghi’s growing intellectual conflict, broader public disagreement on the effectiveness of the current monetary policy mix and the negative effect of distortion in financial markets, markets are still expected more easing. Financial markets are simply projecting that the ECB must do something and that the action will be euro-negative, as the recent experience with the BoJ has shown currency traders. However, we see central bank policy coming to a reflection point. Gone are the days when policy was expected to drive growth but has now shifted back to being a tool to support growth dynamics. Negative rates were just a step too far for most people. It is only a matter of time before central banks accept the fact that they are not in total control with Victorian-era precision and realize that the cost of doing something does not outweigh the cost of doing nothing.

Get The News You Want
Read market moving news with a personalized feed of stocks you care about.
Get The App

In 2017, financial markets will need to learn to live in a world where central banks no longer pretend to offer economic salvation.