Do Insurance Stocks Do Better Than Average Over The Long-Run?
David Merkel | Jun 27, 2012 05:32AM ET
Why should insurance companies be such a good place to invest? That’s a great question, and I will try to outline an answer. Before I do, let me draw a few distinctions:
- I’m not talking about life companies, they are far more capital encumbered then P&C companies.
- I am also not talking about title, mortgage, or finance insurers. They are too risky, and that was my opinion in the early 2000s.
- Health insurers have a different model, much more subject to regulation.
- Many insurance companies that don’t survive 10 years as a public company do poorly. They did not underwrite well.
- Small companies tend to fail disproportionately.
- We aren’t talking about specialty companies.
What I am talking about are non-microcap companies with stable P&C liability structures and conservative reserving. Boring, maybe. Simple, somewhat, but you try setting up a competitor to them. It takes some doing. That is the competitive advantage; it is the barrier to entry. Few companies have diversified liabilities; fewer reserve conservatively.
Thus I highlight P&C companies with ten year track records. Here are the good ones: ACE (ACE), Chubb (CB), Cincinnati Financial (CINF), Donegal Group (DGIC.A, DGIC.B), HCC Insurance (HCC), Markel (MKL), ProAssurance (PRA), RLI Corp. (RLI), Selective Insurance (SIGI), Travelers (TRV), United Fire Group (UFCS), W.R. Berkley (WRB), Arch Capital (ACGL), Alterra Capital Holdings (ALTE), PartnerRe (PRE), Everest Re (RE), Renaissance Re (RNR), White Mountains (WTM), Progressive (PGR), State Auto Financial (STFC), and Erie Indemnity (ERIE).
And here are the trailing ones: American Financial Group (AFG), Baldwin & Lyons (BWIN.A, BWIN.B), EMC Insurance (EMCI), Navigators Group (NAVG), XL Group (|XL), Allegheny Corporation (Y), American National (ANAT), Allstate (ALL), and Horace Mann (HMN).
And two really lousy ones: CNA Insurance (CNA) and Meadowbrook Insurance Group (MIG).
On the whole, the outperformers more than absorb the underperformers, though I can’t prove that, for these reasons:
- Hasn’t happened much in a while, but P&C insurance companies do occasionally die & disappear. Think of PXRe would be an example .
- I may be guilty of selection and survivor bias by sticking with diversified bigger firms that are at least 10 years old. I know of a lot of smaller firms that flame out because they take too much underwriting risk due to hubris and/or inexperience.
To do a complete study, we would have to use the CRSP database, which has all of the data for stocks not currently living. We would see the losses from insolvencies, and the losses/gains thereof. It would take place at the halfway point for US efforts, which would be 4 seconds ahead of the Greeks as they hurried to compete/complete at constant speeds.
Get The News You Want
Trading in financial instruments and/or cryptocurrencies involves high risks including the risk of losing some, or all, of your investment amount, and may not be suitable for all investors. Prices of cryptocurrencies are extremely volatile and may be affected by external factors such as financial, regulatory or political events. Trading on margin increases the financial risks.
Before deciding to trade in financial instrument or cryptocurrencies you should be fully informed of the risks and costs associated with trading the financial markets, carefully consider your investment objectives, level of experience, and risk appetite, and seek professional advice where needed.
Fusion Media would like to remind you that the data contained in this website is not necessarily real-time nor accurate. The data and prices on the website are not necessarily provided by any market or exchange, but may be provided by market makers, and so prices may not be accurate and may differ from the actual price at any given market, meaning prices are indicative and not appropriate for trading purposes. Fusion Media and any provider of the data contained in this website will not accept liability for any loss or damage as a result of your trading, or your reliance on the information contained within this website.
It is prohibited to use, store, reproduce, display, modify, transmit or distribute the data contained in this website without the explicit prior written permission of Fusion Media and/or the data provider. All intellectual property rights are reserved by the providers and/or the exchange providing the data contained in this website.
Fusion Media may be compensated by the advertisers that appear on the website, based on your interaction with the advertisements or advertisers.