Chart Of The Day: Is Alphabet Topping Out?

 | Apr 24, 2018 10:01AM ET

Google (NASDAQ:GOOGL) released its first quarter results yesterday and the stock instantly soared 3 percent on the headline beat, both on the top and bottom lines.

However, when investors got down to deciphering the fine print, they realized that those lines had been artificially stretched, with the help of two changes that had nothing to do with Google's management: an accounting rule and the value of the dollar.

The new accounting rule requires companies to report the change in value of shares owned of private companies, something that until now only be relevant when taking profit by selling those shares. For example, Google bought Uber stock, valued by the privately held company at $4 billion.

However, that valuation multiplied by 12 when Uber sold new shares to SoftBank Group (OTC:SFTBY) in January, at $48 billion. According to the new accounting rule, Google was forced to report a 1,200 percent profit on those shares, even though the tech giant didn't sell those shares and therefore did not in fact incur a profit. This added a value of 2.4 billion after tax, or $3.40 per share. Without this added valuation, Google's net profit would have been only $7 billion, in fact missing estimates.

Additionally, the rising dollar added 3 percent in value, turning what would have otherwise been a $30.07 billion disappointing consensus, into a $31.14 estimate beat.