Buy And Hold: Gold's Broken Strategy

 | Apr 02, 2013 04:28PM ET

The Power of the Pattern suggested on 9/1/2011 -- when gold was trading at $1,828 -- that gold could trade flat to down for years to come. (see the September 2011 post SPY ) became the largest ETF in the world back in 2000 after a 10-year rally, was that a good time to "Buy and Hold" SPY? Buy and Hold didn't work too well -- because 13-years later, SPY was at the same price point. If you traded SPY with a simple 200-day moving average as your buy/sell trigger, you far outpaced buying and holding SPY.

Reformed Broker shared this chart to readers back in February (see post here).

GLD became the largest ETF on the planet in August of 2011, when gold was trading at $1,900 per ounce, at its Fibonacci 261% extension level and at the top of its 10-year rising channel. Not a bad time to hedge or harvest long gold holdings. Once GLD became so big, was that signal to start renting/trading gold versus buying and holding it? So far renting has worked out better than owning.