Are The Stock And Bond Markets Headed For A 2001–2002 Repeat?

 | Jan 18, 2022 01:47AM ET

Leading off articles with a question sets the readers up for an expected answer which involves a prediction for the future.

The fact is no one knows what will happen, and all clients can ask of advisors is that an advisor make probabilistic decisions regarding portfolio construction and asset allocation, that allows the client portfolio to participate in secular bull markets but also preserves capital in secular bear markets.

The period from 2000 to 2009 was a unprecedented decade for US stock returns. Before Morningstar was swallowed up Ibbotson, I always studiously analyzed the annual Ibbotson return data from “Stocks, Bonds, Bills & Inflation.” Ibbotson—when calculating the “average, annual return” for the decade from 2000 to 2009—concluded that the S&P 500 returned approximately 1.25% (I can’t remember the exact figure) per year for the decade, with the benchmark basically earning the dividend for the decade.

Looking at the historical decades beginning with the 1930’s, the decade from 2000 to 2009 was the worst average, annual, return for the S&P 500 since the 1930’s, although the 1930’s was far more negative. In other words, the S&P 500’s decade return was the worst since the 1930’s, albeit positive.

Two weeks into the 2022, the bond market returns are almost universally negative (here’s the postfrom this weekend showing the Treasury yield curve and how the bond funds tracked weekly), with rising Treasury yields, which preceded the October ’87 stock market crash and the events of 2001–2002. In the spring of ’87, the 30-year Treasury bond lost 9 points in a month, and investors often forget that Alan Greenspan raised rates in 1999, which contributed to the 80% 2000–2002 NASDAQ bear market, although if you’d ask me about “attribution” for the 2000–2002, 50% bear market in the S&P 500, I’d say it was primarily the collapse of the tech and large-cap growth bubble, which also included 50% declines in stalwart names like Home Depot (NYSE:HD) and Walmart (NYSE:WMT).

Alpine Macro, which is a macro research firm that (I think) does good work out of Canada, sent this missive along this weekend, which properly sums up what a lot of buy-side investors are thinking right now.

In July, 2020, this post was written, posing the same question I'm addressing now, “Planning for a March, 2000, Moment” (the NASDAQ and S&P 500 both peaked in March, 2000) just so readers and investors remain conscious of history and its important lessons.

I remember March, 2000 to October, 2002, like it was yesterday. Let’s recap the main events:

  • March, 2000, the NASDAQ and S&P 500 put in secular bull market tops with the S&P 500 peaking around 1,550 and the NASDAQ peaking around 5,000–5,100;
  • A 30% drop in the NASDAQ occurred between mid-March ’00 and mid-May ’00;
  • Intel (NASDAQ:INTC) warned in late September ’00, being the first major large-cap tech giant to warn about slowing revenue;
  • Cisco (NASDAQ:CSCO) reported early November ’00 with John Chambers raising guidance on the call;
  • November–December ’00 was the contested Presidential election between Bush 43 and Al Gore;
  • January ’01: Alan Greenspan reduces the fed funds rate to start the new year and the markets rally for about 1 month;
  • February ’01, Cisco reports around February 7, ’01 and lowers guidance for fiscal ’01, after raising guidance just 90 days earlier.
  • The NASDAQ Composite falls 25% in Q1 2001;
  • 9/11: not much else to say about that date. Wall Street closed for 4 days (?) as the US economy comes to a screeching halt;
  • The Fed cuts rates immediately after 9/11, sparking a rally that lasted till the end of 2001;
  • Enron begins to be a problem as the stock price peaked at a high of $90 in mid-2000, but fell to zero by late 2001;
  • In mid-2002, around May–June ’02, I believe it was David Faber of CNBC that broke the story of massive fraud at Worldcom. The CEO Bernie Sullivan was later imprisoned, after blaming his CFO.
  • Around this time the Sarbanes–Oxley law was passed protecting investors from fraudulent account practices by publicly-listed companies. The law also made company executives sign off on the financials, since many CEO’s were blaming their CFO’s for the corrupt practices and claiming innocence about the fraud.
  • After bottoming in late July–October ’02, the S&P 500 500 later put in a triple-bottom just prior to mid-March ’03, which was the ultimate bottom for the stock market, coinciding with the start of Gulf War II in mid-March ’03.
  • The entire peak-to-trough correction for the S&P 500 from March, 2000 to October, 2002, was 50%, the first 50% correction for the S&P 500 since 1973–1974, and only the second 50% correction in the post WW II period.
  • The NASDAQ Composite low 1,000–1,100, was an 80% peak-to-trough correction for the over-the-counter index, taking out the September–October ’98 LongTerm Capital Management lows of 1,475.
Get The News You Want
Read market moving news with a personalized feed of stocks you care about.
Get The App

Writing for Jim Cramer’s TheStreet,com at the time kept me sane. There was another kid who wrote for the site at the time, Jeff Bagley, who was very sharp, went to Fordham b-school, made very good calls, good writer, good analyst, etc. who shot me an AOL instant message at the time, saying, "I come into the office and just lay my head on the desk and hope this goes away.”

What made the bear market tougher to stomach was the actual “real economy,” i.e. home and auto sales and general business activity, was white hot, thanks to the Fed having to cut rates after 9/11 and really injecting a lot of liquidity into the US financial system.

Summary / conclusion: Per the Bespoke Report published every Friday afternoon, sentiment has reached a low (depending on the survey) with AAII not being this bearish since mid-September ’01, while some of the other surveys are now as bearish as they’ve been in the last month. Readers probably only care about how bad any correction will be, and the fact is nobody knows.

This post that was written in early December ’21 for a client dinner where I had to explain that many of the winners of their portfolios for the last 6 years were going to have be trimmed, and this graph / table was shown to the clients to try and crystallize for them how good the recent returns have been over the past 5 years and maybe some capital gain harvesting was warranted. This following table updates the “average, annual, returns” as of 12/31/21: