2 Top Defensive Dividend Stocks

 | Oct 14, 2012 12:49AM ET

With many market observers wondering how long the summer/fall rally will last, we went looking for dividend paying stocks that outperformed the market during the spring pullback AND have also participated in this rally. Not surprisingly, we came up with 2 Utilities stocks, American Electric Power, (AEP), and Next Era Energy, (NEE). Next Era, based in Florida, was formerly known as FPL, (Florida Power & Light).

Both of these stocks are listed in the Utilities section of our High Dividend Stocks By Sector Tables.

Here’s how these 2 electric utilities stocks have performed as of 10/11/12, in both up and down markets. NEE did the best during the pullback, actually rising 4.69%, while AEP only fell -1.18%, while the S&P fell nearly 10%. AEP has reversed itself during the rally, rising over 14%, while NEE has risen 7.57% to date. As the table below shows, they both have risen double-digits on a Pullback vs. Rally net basis, while the S&P has risen just over 2% during the 2 periods: